Walter Hoye

Elizabeth Freeman (Mum Bett)

In Abortion, Special Edition on November 11, 2013 at 12:00 am
Share this page

Without Life, Nothing Matters.

Freedom Suit Series

“Anyone who kidnaps someone and either sells him as a slave or still has him when he is caught must be put to death.” — Exodus 21:16, New Century Version (NCV) 

Freedom suits are legal petitions filed by slaves for freedom. Between America’s colonial period and the American Civil War, a number of civil actions were brought to courts of law by STRONG BLACK WOMEN that challenged both the moral maxim and the legal legitimacy of JUST-SUBJECTION 1 and WRONGFUL-ENSLAVEMENT 2 in America. This series of columns will explore those lawsuits and expose lessons that can be engaged by the Body of Christ and the Pro-Life movement today, in the wake of the 1973 United States Supreme Court (USSC) decisions in Roe v. Wade and Doe v. Bolton.

White Space Holder

Elizabeth Freeman (Mum Bett)

This Ruling Informally Ended Slavery In Massachusetts …

Elizabeth Freeman (Mum Bett)

Elizabeth Freeman (Mum Bett), in early life known as Bett and later Mum Bett (circa 1742 — December 28th, 1829), was among the first Black slaves in Massachusetts to file a “Freedom Suit” and win in the Massachusetts Bay Colony county court under the 1780 Massachusetts constitution,
with a ruling that slavery was illegal. 3

Black, Female, Illiterate And A Slave

“She was a strong, courageous, powerful woman who despite the triple disadvantages of being Black, a woman, and illiterate never saw herself as a victim and instead lived a rich and independent life with much of her time and energy devoted to helping others. She continues to be a role model whose story continues to speak to many women today, rich and poor and Black and White.” 4 — Emilie Piper and David Levinson

Elizabeth was born to enslaved parents (native Africans) around 1742 at the farm of Pieter Hogeboom in Claverack, New York. When Hannah (Hogeboom’s daughter) married Colonel John Ashley of Sheffield, Massachusetts, she was sold as a young teenager, along with her sister, to the newlyweds. On the Sheffield plantation Elizabeth was married, given the name “Bett” and her daughter was given the name “Little Bett.” Bett served Hannah and Colonel Ashley until 1781. It is both note worthy and important to acknowledge here that Elizabeth’s husband (name unknown) was killed while fighting in the American Revolutionary War (1775 — 1783).

According to American novelist, Catharine Maria Sedgwick 5 (December 28th, 1789 — July 31st, 1867) who by the way promoted “Republican motherhood,” 6 Bett was strong spirited and had a healthy sense of self. One day (circa 1780), Hannah Ashley, who was raised in the very strict and Christian Dutch culture of the New York colony, was disciplining Little Bett (that is Bett’s daughter) with a heated shovel. In an effort to protect her daughter, Bett stepped in between the heated shovel 7 and her daughter receiving a very deep wound in her arm. While the wound would eventually heal, Bett was scarred for life and left the wound uncovered as evidence of Hannah’s brutal treatment of slaves. Again, according to Catharine Maria Sedgwick, Bett is quoted saying: “Madam (i.e., Hannah Ashley) never again laid her hand on Lizzy [sic]. I had a bad arm all winter, but Madam had the worst of it. I never covered the wound, and when people said to me, before Madam, ‘Betty, what ails your arm?’ I only answered … ‘ask missis!’ 8 [Now] which was the slave and which was the real misses?”

All Men Are Born Free And Equal

All men are born free and equal, and have certain natural, essential, and unalienable rights; among which may be reckoned the right of enjoying and defending their lives and liberties; that of acquiring, possessing, and protecting property; in fine, that of seeking and obtaining their safety and happiness.” 9 — Massachusetts Constitution, Article 1 (1773)

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” 10 — United States Declaration of Independence (1776)

Sheffield Declaration 1773As a Yale University educated lawyer, wealthy landowner, businessman and leader, Colonel Ashley opened his home to the community. On many occasions, Ashley’s house was the site of political discussions and according to the record, the probable location of the signing of the Sheffield Resolves 11 which predated the United States Declaration of Independence (Thursday, July 4th, 1776). The Sheffield Resolves, also known as the Sheffield Declaration, was a Colonial American petition against British tyranny and a manifesto for individual rights, approved by the Town of Sheffield, Massachusetts, on Tuesday, January 12th, 1773. While it is easy to see how Article 1 of the Massachusetts Constitution (above) was echoed in the most famous line of Thomas Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence 12 (above) three (3) years later, it is also easy to understand how such words as “all men are born free and equal” caught Bett’s attention as they were being read at Sheffield’s home.

The 1781 Berkshire County Case Of Brom And Bett vs. Ashley

“I heard that paper read yesterday, that says, all men are created equal, and that every man has a right to freedom. I’m not a dumb critter; won’t the law give me my freedom?” 13 — Elizabeth Freedom (Mum Bett)

Court Order To Free Elizabeth FreemanAfter overhearing discussions of the new Massachusetts State Constitution, the Bill of Rights and that all people were born free and equal in the Ashely’s home, Bett believed the law had to be applicable to her as well. As such, Bett asked for the counsel of a young abolition-minded lawyer named Theodore Sedgwick 14 to help her use the law to sue for freedom. Sedgwick believed slaves were indeed human beings, accepted her case and that of Brom, another of Colonel Ashley’s slaves. Next, Sedgwick recruited the help of the founder of America’s first law school (located at Litchfield, Connecticut), Tapping Reeve. When the case of Brom and Bett vs. Ashley 15 was heard before the County Court of Common Pleas in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, Sedgwick and Reeve argued that the constitutional provision that “all men are born free and equal” nullified the slave system in the state. In the end, the jury ruled in Bett’s favor and found that: “Brom and Bett are not, nor were they at the time of the purchase of the original writ the legal Negro of the said John Ashley.” So in August of 1781, the court assessed damages of thirty (30) shillings, awarded both plaintiffs (i.e., Brom and Bett) compensation for their labor and Bett became the First Black American Woman To Be Recognized As A Legal Person And Set Free under the Massachusetts State Constitution. Although this victory was a lower court decision with very limited influence, the case was a serious blow to slavery in Massachusetts.

Open Letter To The Church

LESSON: Personhood Resonates And Registers In Black America

A Lesson We Can Learn From The Case Of Elizabeth Freeman (Mum Bett)

“Any time, any time while I was a slave, if one minute’s freedom had been offered to me, and I had been told I must die at the end of that minute, I would have taken it just to stand one minute on God’s airth [sic] a free woman.” — Elizabeth Freedom (Mum Bett) 16

Emilie Piper - Mumbet - Story of Elizabeth FreemanClearly, Bett understood what it’s like not to be a legal person in the American colonies and would rather live a single minute free and die, than live her life as a slave17 The fight for personhood is found everywhere in Black American history. Personhood strikes a chord that runs deep in the experiences of Black Americans. The wholly heartfelt desire for Personhood strikes a chord that rings so true and runs so deep in my people that it can even be found in the souls of those who have been violently subjected to slavery since the American Colony of Virginia’s “Hereditary Slave Law” of 1661. The reality is Personhood resonates in the heart, registers in the mind, generates soul searching conversation and has the power to reconcile the very strained relationship between the Pro-Life movement and communities of color. In Black America, Personhood speaks to the need to have the words “we hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” apply to all human life and not just some human life.

The Book Cover: One Minute A Free WomanToday, Alveda King, daughter of A.D. King and niece of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. says: “The cause of personhood is the final chapter of the civil rights movement18 And each person who’s spared because of it will receive a priceless gift — the chance to write the chapters of his or her own life story.” Certainly, Bett received this gift from her freedom suit and wrote the last chapters of her life as a free woman. While Bett’s real age is not known, her tombstone estimates that she died at the age of eight-five (85). As such, in December of 1829 Elizabet Freeman (Mum Bett) was buried in the Sedgwick family plot in Stockbridge, Massachusetts. Her tombstone, inscription reads as follows:

Elizabeth Freeman's (Mum Bett) TombstoneELIZABETH FREEMAN, known by the name of MUMBET died Dec. 28th 1829. Her supposed age was 85 Years. She was born a slave and remained a slave for nearly thirty years; She could neither read nor write, yet in her own sphere she had no superior or equal. She neither wasted time nor property. She never violated a trust, nor failed to perform a duty. In every situation of domestic trial, she was the most efficient helper and the tenderest friend. Good mother, farewell.” 19

Could it be that victory for the Pro-Life movement will come only when we all work together, hand in hand, as brothers and sisters in the body of Christ? Could it be that victory will only come when there is room at the table and provision made for strategies like Personhood? Could it be that victory in the fight to end abortion on demand anywhere and everywhere it exists in the world, cannot be realized without leadership from members within communities of color? Could it be that victory in the public square, from the righteous reign of Christ on the hearts and minds of men and women, will not come until His Body lives out the reality that “she is not the master or the servant of the state, but rather the conscience of the state?” 20

Yeah, I think it could.

Brothers, we need to talk.


 In my very, very strong opinion, THE BIBLE DOES NOT JUSTIFY SLAVERY. If pastors (christian leaders) of the South taught their congregants to obey the Mosaic laws that criminalized kidnapping human beings, the harsh treatment of servants, the return of runaway servants and without preferring the rich over the poor or men over women, held everyone accountable for their own actions in the public square, slavery would not have existed.


Deuteronomy 24:7 says: “If someone kidnaps a fellow Israelite, either to make him a slave or sell him, the kidnapper must be killed. You must get rid of the evil among you.”

Harsh Treatment

Exodus 21:26,27 says: “If a man hits his male or female slave in the eye, and the eye is blinded, the man is to free the slave to pay for the eye. If a master knocks out a tooth of his male or female slave, the man is to free the slave to pay for the tooth.”

Runaway Servants

Deuteronomy 23:15-16 say: “If an escaped slave comes to you, do not hand over the slave to his master. Let the slave live with you anywhere he likes, in any town he chooses. Do not mistreat him.”

The New Testament speaks equally as strong against the kidnapping of human beings (which is the basis of slavery) as the Old Testament. Please read the Apostle Paul’s warning against false teaching in 1st Timothy 1:8-10 (NCV): “But we know that the law is good if someone uses it lawfully. We also know that the law is not made for good people but for those who are against the law and for those who refuse to follow it. It is for people who are against God and are sinful, who are unholy and ungodly, who kill their fathers and mothers, who murder, who take part in sexual sins, who have sexual relations with people of the same sex, WHO SELL SLAVES, who tell lies, who speak falsely, and who do anything against the true teaching of God.

“Perhaps the most compelling argument AGAINST SLAVERY in the New Testament is Paul’s letter to Philemon, in which the Apostle asks Onesimus (a fellow Christian) to free his Christian slave.


01. A paradox noted by Edlie Wong in her book “Neither Fugitive Nor Free” (2009), slave states had statutes that provided for slaves to sue for “wrongful enslavement”, based on slave laws that established “just subjection”, page 5 and 153 (
02. Ibid.
03. Elizabeth Freeman (Mum Bett), Wikipedia (
04. Tammis Coffin, “Elizabeth Freeman’s Life Researched in New Book”, (
05. Catharine Maria Sedgwick, Wikipedia (
06. Republican Motherhood, Wikipedia (
07. Elizabeth Freeman (Mum Bett), “Biography and Trial” Wikipedia (
08. Charles Dickens, William Harrison Ainsworth, Albert Smith, George Cruikshank, “Bentley’s Miscellany”, Volume 34, page 418. (
09. Constitution of Massachusetts “Part the First: A Declaration of the Rights of the Inhabitants of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts” (
10. The Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson, “In Congress, July 4th, 1776 The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America”. (
11. Sheffield Declaration, Wikipedia (
12. The Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson, “In Congress, July 4th, 1776 The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America”. (
13. Charles Dickens, William Harrison Ainsworth, Albert Smith, George Cruikshank, “Bentley’s Miscellany”, Volume 34, page 421. (
14. Theodore Sedgwick, Wikipedia (
15. Massachusetts Judicial Branch, “The Massachusetts Constitution, Judicial Review and Slavery”, The Mum Bett Case (
16. Charles Dickens, William Harrison Ainsworth, Albert Smith, George Cruikshank, “Bentley’s Miscellany”, Volume 34, page 421. (
17. Mumbet — Story of Elizabeth Freeman, Co-authors David Levinson and Emilie Piper discuss their new book “One Minute a Free Woman, Elizabeth Freeman and the Struggle For Freedom” at the Litchfield History Museum. (
18. Alveda C. King, “The Final Chapter”, California Equal Rights Amendment Campaign (
19. John Sedgwick, “In My Blood” Six Generations of Madness and Desire In An American Family (
20. Martin Luther King, Jr., “Strength to Love,” Published in 1963. This is a collection of classic sermons preached by Martin Luther King, Jr., page 64. (

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: